Wednesday, 9 May 2012

Is new knowledge worth the change of previously accepted facts

  An interesting issue I found on the Internet recently was the debate about the existence of particles faster than light, neutrinos. The particles have been 'discovered' during test with a 30km long particle accelerator designed and built to try and understand black holes and the forming of the universe. However there is rumor of a revolutionary discovery that could spell the end of the theory of relativity as we know it. When Einstein devised this theory he put forward that mass and time was relative to the speed of light, if something surpassed the speed of light that thing would have infinite mass and be suspended in time. The neutrinos that are thought to exist after violent colisions between protons, can totally change this theory, rendering it almost useless.

I found this issue interesting because we built that facility in the hope of advancing science but we may have completely undermined the essence of scientifical knowledge, which leads me to my main point, would we be better off without the knowledge of neutrinos? Should we be oblivious to the fact that our environment is not how we like to think it is, maybe?   I think not, I think that we should constantly be try to prove ourselves wrong, for without failure we would not know how to succeed. If we do not fail at something how can we know that it was or was not real. Yes there will be new science textbooks to be made, yes some will argue, but we would know! Knowledge is the only thing we can prove we have, the more we have, the greater the chance of us actually existing is likely.

2 comments:

  1. How would you measure 'being better off'? How would you measure 'being worth the change of previously accepted facts'?

    Your final statement is an interesting claim with an interesting conclusion. How do you justify this?

    In your three posts you have explored some interesting thoughts. It would have been good to see a more detailed, probing analysis of each question, with a bit more rigour to your argument.

    For your next posting, perhaps you could put together a more detailed, stepwise exploration of a topic.

    Keep up the good work, Quentin.

    ReplyDelete
  2. 1. Why is there nothing published since 9 May ?

    2. Where is your essay on '12 Angry Men' ?

    ReplyDelete